[time-nuts] Possible HP 10811 instability clue Cont’d.
bruce.griffiths at xtra.co.nz
Fri Oct 8 00:50:11 EDT 2010
Perry Sandeen wrote:
> Wrote<Some on this list mentioned having had less-than-optimal performance with their HP 10811 series oscillators. James Miller G3RUH made a slight mention of optimizing performance by readjusting the set point temperature in one of his phase detector articles. He said though time consuming the results were worth the effort.
> Replied:<Regardless of isolated anecdotal data on one oscillator, it is probably not advisable to change the set point.
> Answer: Agree. My comments were made about someone with a “wonky” oscillator that that this MIGHT be part of the problem.
> Replied: The majority of 10811 crystals do NOT have a turnover, only a region of low tempco around 82 degrees.
> Answer: I respectfully disagree. First isn’t a region of low tempco another way of saying turning point?
A turning point of the frequency vs temperature curve is a location
where the the tempco is zero.
It may be located at a maximum, at a minimum or at a point of inflection.
> Semantics aside, I believe that they do have a turning point that is selected. This is why. HP selects 41 separate resistance values to obtain 41 different oven temperatures between 80.0C to 84.0 C in .1 degree increments. Now if that isn’t finding a turning point I don’t know what is.
Not so, it merely reflects that there is a temperature, for a particular
10811A crystal, at which the tempco is minimised somewhere in the (80C,
It also indicates that an accuracy of around 0.1 C or better in locating
this minimum is desirable.
Thermistor tolerances will increase the apparent temperature range somewhat.
> I believe that is why they say if the oscillator fails it needs to be repaired at the factory.
> Wrote:<Instead of that, change the circuit to B-mode and optimize the heat between the two heater resistors for maximum thermal gain (you should be able to get 1000). Then change the circuit back to normal.
> Answer: I have no idea B-mode is. Would you please expand on it and how to do it? It could be very useful.
The B mode is a mode of oscillation of the crystal which has a
relatively large tempco and thus it can be used to measure changes in
the crystal temperature.
The normal mode of operation is the C mode which has a much lower tempco.
To allow oscillation in the B mode the mode suppression components in
the 10811A oscillator need to be disconnected.
For some further detail on this read the HP journal article on the 10811A.
More information about the time-nuts