[time-nuts] 5680A update (temperature stabilization)
lists at rtty.us
Tue Jan 17 16:53:56 EST 2012
Since they used a magnetic outer case I'd keep it in place. Rb's are
sensitive to magnetic field. Anything that attenuates external fields is
helping you out.
From: time-nuts-bounces at febo.com [mailto:time-nuts-bounces at febo.com] On
Behalf Of paul swed
Sent: Tuesday, January 17, 2012 4:02 PM
To: beale; Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement
Subject: Re: [time-nuts] 5680A update (temperature stabilization)
You have answered a couple of questions for me. The heat sink inside is
small so its easy to see why all sides of the case should be close in
Like you in tinkering, I attached 4 reasonable size heat sinks with the
case off and noticed I could drop the internal heat sink to 115 degrees.
Granted everything cooks inside but it seems a bad way to run things.
Though the xtal does need the stability.
I think I may follow your lead and attach an external sink to dump extra
heat from the regulators. No fan just open air.
I hate fans. ;-)
On Tue, Jan 17, 2012 at 3:44 PM, beale <beale at bealecorner.com> wrote:
> I tried a simple bang-bang controller (LM35 temp sensor+comparator+pass
> transistor to drive a small fan) with the LM35 taped to the center of a
> large finned heatsink. The FE-5680A+heatsink are sitting upside down, so
> heatsink fins point up. LM35 leads wired with 34 gauge wire, which is
> along heatsink surface. The fan cycle time was about 20 seconds, and the
> peak variation measured at the LM35 was about 0.2 degrees. Now, of course
> what I am controlling is the top surface of the heatsink. What's the
> temperature variation inside? Well, another temperature sensor, a
> thermistor full bridge attached to the center top surface of the 5680A
> (which is underneath, in my setup) indicates that surface varies only 4
> millidegrees C in the short term (one fan cycle) due to the thermal mass
> the assembly. However, long term it drifts much more along with ambient,
> because I do not have good insulation around the body of the 5680A. I plan
> to put it in a well-insulated box with just the heatsink exposed, so
> all the heat transfer happens at the heatsink fin surface, which I am
> controlling. I am guessing I can manage 0.01 C stability inside the box
> that way.
> -John Beale
> > -------Original Message-------
> > From: WarrenS <warrensjmail-one at yahoo.com>
> > To: Discussion of precise time and frequency measurement <
> time-nuts at febo.com>
> > Subject: Re: [time-nuts] 5680A update
> > Sent: 17 Jan '12 11:52
> > to Chris
> > What I've seen is that holding 0.1 C AT the SENSOR is pretty easy,
> > (Lady Heather will hold the TBolt's sensor to 0.01 deg using just a
> > AND if you blow a lot of air around, then keeping the air gradients
> inside a
> > closed 'oven box' below 0.1 deg is also NO problem.
> > to Bert
> > Have you measure what the Temperature coeff is over normal room changes
> > and without the addition of the temp controller?
> > What is the best configuration to keep the fe5680 freq constant?
> > For the LPRO, what I found by experiment worked best for me is to place
> > unit upside down so the heat sink was on top.
> > If any air was blown on the non heat sink side, that would greatly
> > the frequency stability in a bad way.
> > A way to get around the compromise of where the best place is to put
> > sensor, either close to the heat source or close to the device.
> > Best answer is BOTH. The way to get high end control and a much more
> > control loop, is to use TWO temperature sensors.
> > Put one temperature sensor near the Heat source and a second one at the
> > place you want to hold constant.
> > Then in effect 'AC couple' the heat source sensor, so that it does the
> > course temperature control.
> > One way to do this is to set it up so that the heat source sensor is
> > feed-forward or "D" input for the main sensor PID control loop.
> > Another way to set it up is so that the device sensor's error slowly
> > the temperature set-point of the heat source's temperature control
> > ws
> > ***************
> > >I am, as I reported previously using a SMD LM335 away from the fan and
> > > down with a screw and a small bracket and I get consistent .1 C. I do
> > >think that I would get 1 E-12 over weeks when my lab has seen more
> > >5C temperature changes if my temperature readings are not correct.
> > >Do not forget this was a quick and dirty setup, the final product will
> > > more professional.
> > >Bert Kehren
> > *************
> > albertson.chris at gmail.com writes:
> > On Tue, Jan 17, 2012 at 8:38 AM, <EWKehren at aol.com> wrote:
> > >>> I am using a fan that holds it within .1 C Its been month since I
> > >>>measured it but I did report it here and I think it is 42.7C.
> > >>0.1C is very good for just using a fan. What is the fe5680
> > >>mounted to? just the heat sink or is there a thick metal plate.
> > >>Also what are you using as a heat sensor. Is the sensor press fit
> > >>the heat sink or. I do remember reading about your temperature
> > >>controlled fan but not the 0.1C part. I'd have guessed you could
> > >>do about 2.0C with a setup like yours.
> > >>Chris Albertson
> > >>Redondo Beach, California
> > _______________________________________________
> > time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts at febo.com
> > To unsubscribe, go to
> > and follow the instructions there.
> time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts at febo.com
> To unsubscribe, go to
> and follow the instructions there.
time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts at febo.com
To unsubscribe, go to
and follow the instructions there.
More information about the time-nuts