[time-nuts] Modulation Domain Analysis
Richard (Rick) Karlquist
richard at karlquist.com
Tue Jun 16 18:17:05 EDT 2015
That's interesting. I worked for the HP Santa Clara Division
from 1979 until just before it was closed in 1998. I
forget who "invented" MDA at SCD, but it was hyped like
it was some new concept and I never heard anything about
Many times someone would come to me and ask me about
some "new" bright idea they had, and I would tell them
"Yes, I can confirm that your idea is excellent, because
I read the original paper on it that was published in
19XX." It is interesting that people would often get
mad at me, as if it is my fault they reinvented the wheel.
If only I known about your HP Journal article, I could
have throw it up to the "innovators" at SCD.
Before I worked for HP, an HP Journal article came out
about fractional-N synthesizers, and everyone at Zeta
Labs was anxious to use the technology in the Zeta
Labs designs. Except one guy, who pointed out that
he had invented frac-N 11 years previously, and he
called it "digiphase." I've never heard anyone at
HP ever acknowledge that guy.
Rick (now retired from HP/Agilent/Keysight)
On 6/16/2015 12:54 PM, Robert Gilchrist Huenemann wrote:
> I stumbled onto the time nuts list from a posting on modulation domain analysis a couple of weeks ago. I am enjoying the discussion.
> I want to comment on modulation domain analysis, or phase digitizing. This is a technique that uses a period mode frequency counter, or two such counters back to back, to recover the modulation history of a frequency modulated waveform.
> This technique was first used in the HP9540 automated transceiver test system. This system was described in the August 1973 HP Journal. The HP9540 used a single HP5326 period mode counter with a 10 MHz clock. At that time, no counter was available with a higher clock frequency.
> A breadboard system was assembled as part of the HP9540 development effort which used two HP5326 counters back to back. To insure that alternate periods were measured, the second HP5326 ran off the gate output of the first. However, it was realized that the characteristics of the HP9540 and its specific application were such that two counters were not required. Please refer to my HP Journal article for details.
> The HP9540 was developed at HP's Automatic Measurement Division. This division was disbanded in 1974.
> Modulation Domain Analysis and Phase Digitizing were terms that came into use with the later development of specialized stand alone instruments that combined computational capability, back to back period mode counters, higher clock frequencies, interpolation and algorithms for various measurements. All of these were worthwhile improvements on the basic technique first used in the HP9540.
> I would be happy to answer questions. Thank you for allowing me to post this information.
> Robert Gilchrist Huenemann, M.S.E.E.
> 120 Harbern Way
> Hollister, CA 95023-9708
> bobgh at razzolink.com
> Extra Class Amateur Radio License W6RFW
> IEEE Life Member 01189471
> This email has been checked for viruses by Avast antivirus software.
> time-nuts mailing list -- time-nuts at febo.com
> To unsubscribe, go to https://www.febo.com/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/time-nuts
> and follow the instructions there.
More information about the time-nuts